It's eleven in the morning and my breath smells of whiskey.

I want to be clear, before you stage an intervention, that I feel no shame about this whatsoever — because what I have is the good part of whiskey. Whiskey, if you examine it honestly, comes in two halves. There is the half that makes a man text his ex at midnight, deliver an unsolicited lecture on the fall of Rome to a stranger at a bus stop, and wake at 3am with the cold certainty that he has somehow offended a man named Gary. And then there is the other half: the flavour. The warm spice, the toasted grain, the whisper of a charred oak barrel. The sophisticated part. The part that shows up on time, wears a decent jacket, and has never once suggested karaoke.

For most of human history these two halves came bolted together, sold by the bottle, non-negotiable. You wanted the flavour, you took the consequences. This struck me, for years, as a poor arrangement.

And then I found a bar of chocolate that had performed the surgery for me — separating the flavour from the folly, and delivering the first without a drop of the second. Which is how I came to have whiskey on my breath at eleven in the morning, at my desk, entirely sober, and pleased with myself about it.

The bar is Goodnow Farms' Putnam Rye Whiskey, and the more you pull on its threads, the more improbable and lovely it becomes.

Two makers, one small corner of the map

Start with the chocolate. Goodnow Farms is the work of Tom and Monica Rogan, made on a 225-year-old farm in Sudbury, Massachusetts — a genuine New England farmhouse operation where they perform every step of the process themselves, down to pressing their own single-origin cocoa butter, a fussy and time-consuming thing almost no one else bothers to do, and hand-wrapping every bar. They are, by any measure, among the very best bean-to-bar makers in the United States.

Then the whiskey. Putnam Rye comes from Boston Harbor Distillery, and the name carries a story most people sip right past. The distillery occupies a historic building erected by one Silas Putnam, a nineteenth-century Boston industrialist who figured out how to automate the hot-forged horseshoe nail — the Putnam Nail Factory — and proceeded to supply nails to both sides of the American Civil War, which is either shrewd or morally flexible depending on your mood. The whiskey is named in tribute to his inventive, entrepreneurial, faintly opportunistic spirit. It's a proper rye: ninety-five percent rye grain, aged harborside in new American oak barrels charred to the highest level, all blueberry-pie nose and crème-brûlée-and-spice finish.

A small historical footnote worth having, because it makes the bar taste better: rye was the original American whiskey. Before bourbon took the crown, before Prohibition knocked the whole enterprise flat, rye was what this country drank — George Washington himself ran one of the largest rye distilleries of his era at Mount Vernon. Rye's slow comeback over the last couple of decades, led by exactly this kind of small, stubborn, craft distiller, is one of the quiet good-news stories of American drinking. So the whiskey in this bar isn't just a flavour. It's a small act of historical restoration.

Two New England makers, then, a short drive apart, both obsessive, both reviving old crafts. That alone would make a decent bar. But it's the third thread that turns it into something I actually want to tell you about.

The bird that ties it together

The cacao comes from Zorzal, in the Dominican Republic — and Zorzal is not an ordinary farm. It's the beating agricultural heart of Reserva Privada Zorzal, the Dominican Republic's first private nature reserve, a thousand-acre stretch of mountain rainforest in the Cordillera Septentrional established in 2012. Roughly seventy percent of it is designated "forever wild" — untouchable rainforest, protected in perpetuity. The rest grows organic cacao under the shade of the forest canopy, the trees tucked in among the wild ones rather than replacing them.

And the whole thing exists because of a bird.

Zorzal is the Spanish word for thrush — specifically the Bicknell's Thrush, a small, speckled, unremarkable-looking songbird with one remarkable habit. It is one of the rarest and most threatened migratory birds in the Americas, with perhaps eighty thousand left in the wild, and it splits its year between two homes. It winters in the mountain forests of the Dominican Republic. And it summers — this is the part that made me put down my coffee — in the high forests of the northeastern United States and eastern Canada. Vermont. New Hampshire. The White Mountains. New England.

The reserve was built to protect that bird's winter home, and the cacao was planted to fund the protecting — a working demonstration that you can grow world-class chocolate and safeguard an endangered species on the same land, at the same time. Every bar of Zorzal cacao is, in a small and literal way, a donation to a rainforest and a songbird. As the people at Zorzal like to put it, it turns out chocolate can be a force for international conservation.

Now hold the whole thing in your head at once. The chocolate is made in Massachusetts. The whiskey is distilled in Boston. And the cacao is grown to shelter a bird that spends its summers in the New England hills above both of them, then flies two thousand miles south to the Dominican mountains where that very cacao grows. The bird flies the exact route the bar does. Everything in this square of chocolate migrates between New England and the Dominican Republic — the thrush, and now, in reverse, the chocolate. I promise you nobody sat down and designed that. It's just true, and it's the kind of true that's better than anything a marketing department could invent.

And, finally, the taste

You could know none of this and still be won over, which is the real test of a bar. The 77% dark base leads with deep, rounded cocoa and a touch of gentle fruit — that's the Zorzal cacao, bright and apricot-edged from its shady mountain upbringing. Then, mid-palate, the rye arrives and starts to sing: warm baking spice, toasted grain, the soft vanilla-and-wood note of a charred barrel. The finish lingers and mellows, whiskey-sweet, and asks politely for another piece. It is grown-up chocolate in the best sense — complex, unhurried, a little bit serious, and completely delicious.

Here's the part I'll just say straight, without the jokes. This is one of our favourite bars, full stop. Whenever we run a blind tasting with friends — labels off, prices hidden, nobody's opinion allowed to lean on anyone else's — this bar finishes number one. Not most of the time. Every time. It sits at #4 in our Top 100, and frankly the only mystery is how it isn't higher.

It's in stock, it's ready to ship, and it will put whiskey on your breath at whatever hour you consider civilised. No consequences. No Gary. Just the good part.

Taste it → 

The maker & the bar

Goodnow Farms — Sudbury, Massachusetts. Bean-to-bar on a 225-year-old farm; own freshly-pressed single-origin cocoa butter; hand-wrapped.

Putnam Rye Whiskey 77% — a collaboration with Putnam Rye Whiskey (Boston Harbor Distillery, Boston). Single-origin Dominican cacao from Reserva Zorzal, a bird-sanctuary agroforestry farm; single-origin Esmeraldas cocoa butter; real rye whiskey aged in charred oak. Deep cocoa, warm rye spice, toasted grain, lingering barrel finish. 55g. #4 in the World's Top 100. Vegan · Gluten-free · Soy-free. In stock.

Pair it with — a neat pour of Putnam Rye to mirror the barrel warmth; a tawny port or aged Madeira; or, without alcohol, a smoky black tea or roasted coffee. Alongside: toasted pecans or rye crispbread.

Taste it →